What are the fonts used here? Thank you!

Bodoni Egyptian ExtraBold  Suggested by donshottype 
Blackstock  Suggested by donshottype 

Wood-engraved illustration show the Remington New Model Army Revolver made c. 1863 - 1875.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remington_Model_1858
which establishes an approximate date for the advert.
Bodoni Egyptian Pro ExtraBold could be used to approximate the bold font.
Further digging might turn up a closer substitute.

Much closer in style. Only offered as a distressed version.
No lower case.
Ampersand http://www.myfonts.com/fonts/aerotype/blackstock/pro/glyphs.html#glyphs/633212/25

Thanks for the suggestions. I do like the second one better and I might be able to get away with using all caps.