Yes, I know, it's a long shot but....

Someone stole the 1 from my house and I can't find a replacement to buy, so I want to make one. The issue is I want to find a font close enough to do some work and make a 1. You can almost see the outline from the old number 1, but I'd need something more exact to make a replacement.

Anyone out there have an idea? It doesn't have to be the exact font, I just want something that'd look good so I can make a matching replacement 1.

Cheltenham Ultra  Suggested by DPape 

The cheaper Standard Ultra is the same but does not have a sample available so scroll down to the Pro Ultra. A screen-dump will give you something to work with.