I tried Sackers Gothic, Sweet Sans, Engravers Gothic, ITC Blair, etc. Even stretching them slightly isn't an exact match. Any ideas? Custom font, perhaps?

Sackers Gothic  Suggested by Heron2001 

My thought - This is from a social card that was engraved. Which just by the nature of engraving, would change the width, feel of the type. So trying to match perfectly (by computer) will never get you there.

Closest I see would be Sackers Gothic - and step on it...