EDITED
I should have refreshed the page before posting this. Jerseygirl had already found the font.
ORIGINAL POST:
Don't have a distressed or rubber stamp version of these gothic or grotesque letters, but for a substitute rubber stamp gothic -- NOT THE FONT -- you could use Profumo, which has a similar ampersand.
A similar clean version of the ampersand is found in Railroad Gothic and Gothic RR Bold Condensed http://www.myfonts.com/fonts/redrooster/gothic-rr/bold-condensed/glyphs.html#glyphs/618440/9

Looks like a logo, so there may not be an exact match
Similarities to various Caslon fonts, Caslon Bold, Caslon 3 etc. but these are NOT THE FONT
The leg on _R_ is similar to Perpetua Bold
http://myfonts.us/td-CiMwTu

Metalista is NOT THE FONT but has some similarities.

Hefeweizen DTD is NOT THE FONT but has some similarities.

Designed by "Will" a "graphic designer for hire" in the U.K.
See letterpress business cards:
http://www.blushpublishing.co.uk/pages/desypha
Currently active on Twitter
https://twitter.com/desypha

Info at linkedin
https://www.linkedin.com/company/desypha
Has a page on dribble, but last entry is in 2014
https://dribbble.com/desypha
His website is no longer active.

Perhaps geometric lettering rather than a font.
Some similarities to German "Jackboot" blackletter fonts of the 1930s: Element, National etc.

Logo made from NewsFlash BB
The _A_ is _U_ flipped and with crossbar added.
The _C_ is _O_ with a section clipped out.
Slight thickening of the letters for effect
An example of how logo makers can make easy bucks with a few minutes work tweaking a free font

Width narrowed for _PUERTO VALLARTA_
Other words are not edited

Originally designed by Rudolf Koch for the Klingspor font foundry in Offenbach, Germany in 1925 and sold as Wilhelm Klingspor Gotisch
Pay versions
Wilhelm Klingspor Gotisch
http://myfonts.us/td-sHzlq3
Wilhelm Klingspor Schrift
http://myfonts.us/td-xHh53a
Note: the _k_ in Killigrew is a tz-ligature in the pay versions

The letters could perhaps have been made by modifying ITC Machine Medium

Custom logo for the Atlanta Hawks
More letters from another version of the logo

Usually described as having a "Latin" or triangular serif. No fonts in this category are an exact match.

For _C_ and _U_ this is a poor quality digitization of Joseph Gille's font of about 1820
Cleaned up versions as:
Gille Classic
http://myfonts.us/td-S62iGZ
Home Style
http://myfonts.us/td-TChtFY
Madame
http://myfonts.us/td-XwUV2C
Other names Circus and Roma. No legitimate downloads.

For _R_ and _S_
Also a slightly different cleaned up version as Main Strike
http://myfonts.us/td-s2G5Nk
Another free version: Ringmaster JF
http://www.moorstation.org/typoasis/designers/jfs/ringmaster.html

For _ife is a_

Horizontally expanded for _Metal_
As is for _Central_
Minor edit: top of _n_ smoothed