I've been searching for the perfect script font. Is it my imagination that fonts move from page to page? For instance if I saw "Menleader" on page 36 now and then look at "Edwardian" on page 59, I may not find Menleader on page 36 again. Another related question is "How are new fonts added? Are they just randomly inserted on any page? I don't think they're added to the very end, are they?

By default, fonts are sorted by popularity. Popularity is calculated every day.
There's a dropdown menu to sort fonts by "newest" if you prefer. Which means oldest fonts will be on last page.