Tiffany  Suggeriti da JoCatalparo 
Benguiat Caslon Plain  Suggeriti da donshottype 
Emfatick  Suggeriti da donshottype 

Looks familiar. Do you have any more letters?

donshottype I only have this word, sadly,


Regards

The ball terminals on the ligature _fi_ and _c_ in Benguiat Caslon Plain are closer than Tiffany.
Set the word _fiction_ and the letterer automatically produces an _fi_ ligature.
But neither Benguiat Caslon Plain nor Tiffany are a perfect match to _fiction_.

Emfatick NF is also based on Ed Benguiat's Caslon Black, but does not have the same _fi_ ligature.
It is an inexpensive substitute for your mystery font -- assuming it is a font and not a custom creation.
Photolettering seems to sell Benguiat Caslon Plain only by subscription.

donshottype, thanks for the help! Much appreciated!

JoCatalparo, thanks so much. Very kind of you.