I know that the "Freshman" is the font Dead Kansas, but I'm not sure what the "Hamilton High School" and "2016" is.

Gloucester  Vorgeschlagen von fmontpetit 
Haettenschweiler  Vorgeschlagen von loguz 

I couldn't find a distressed version, but this font is based on Gloucester ou perhaps Cheltenham.

loguz, OP asked for the other one. The one that looks like Haettenschweiler is actually Dead Kansas.

Hehe, yeah, these things happens when we don't read descriptions Welcome to "I don't read that s%$t" Club

ok