I would like to find a font that has the inner highlight already there. I had to draw these lines and it's time consuming. Any help is greatly appreciated!

Superstar M54  Vorgeschlagen von pilaster 

Superstar M54 for your basic letterforms then create a graphic style to reuse?

I used Porn star as the base and drew the inner highlight marks. I was hoping there was a font out there somewhere that already had the inner highlight.

Hmmm. None that I know. Sorry. Others may have other ideas. (personally I'd just have made a Illustrator Graphic Style of the effects so I could reuse them with whatever text, including the arch warp without having to hand draw them each time)