I'm looking for a font that's as close as possible to this hand-lettering in the picture. Thanks!

English Gothic, 17th C.  Vorgeschlagen von JSFoster75 

Pick ya' out one...
http://www.dafont.com/theme.php?cat=401&text=Popcorn&fpp=50

The "P" is different, but this might work for you...

Thanks, These are all great. I guess I should have just checked the Gothic section first! XD