I need to create a mock magazine cover using the font show here and on Cigar Aficionado's website. It looks very close to Times New Roman but it's not. Anyone have any clue as to what it is? Thanks in advance.

Garamond Pro  Suggested by pilaster 


Apple Garamond  Suggested by biggie2970 

the 'fi' ligature in 'aficionado' is a modified 'f' and 'i' rather than the 'fi' ligature from the font.