What font is this? It looks exceedingly simple, like Arial with serifs, but the apostrophe is unique and I haven't been able to match it with anything.

Minion Cond SemiBold  Suggested by jerseygirl 

That's basically it, thank you!!! The apostrophe is still different but screw it, I'll cut it out from the original and paste.

how is it different?

Hmm, it shows up differently on my computer...

there is a difference between apostrophe and single quote mark

Got it, thanks!