I first assumed that the "4" and “STATE” are in Clarendon font, but that doesn't seem to be the case, unless I don't have the correct style. The lower case of “Maintenance Supply” MAY be in Brush Script MT, just not 100% sure. I can't find the “M” and “S” in that same text, though...quite a few fonts come up similar in searches (including Loki Cola, which is as close as it gets using my eyes).

I've given up...I'm hardly the expert! Thank you for any assistance.

Commercial Script  Suggested by fmontpetit 

M and S

Looks great. Thank you.

The rest of that text (Maintenance Supply) is in fact Brush Script.

Now, I've been told that "STATE" is Century Schoolbook Bold, which seems accurate. The "4" just doesn't fit it, though, no matter how much I tinker with the style properties.

Anyone have an idea? I expected it to be the same font as the other, but I was incorrect.

The 4 may very well be a modified Cushing Heavy.

Easily the closest yet. All but the base of the "4" matches, and that's usually where I find myself out of answers. It's a perfect block shape in the logo, while the Cushing Heavy font (which I had on my computer, but must have looked over it) kind of slopes down (on each side) from the main vertical down to the base.

If this guy wasn't so dead-set on using the EXACT logo, I'd settle for a font that is pretty close. I just can't find it...and it feels like I've looked through roughly 1,000 fonts already.

Again, I appreciate the help with this (those that have replied, and those who may down the road).

Suppose I could adjust the base manually, since I'm going to have to edit in the extension from the middle of the number.

You could also try WSI's Chesterfield Condensed, stretched a bit.